Connect with us

Football

10 Thoughts on Oklahoma State’s 30-27 Victory Against Arizona State

Big 12 After Dark.

Published

on

[Devin Wilber/PFB]

Support PFB with a PFB+ membership — $8 a month or $50 for a year.

TEMPE, Arizona — If you went to bed at halftime, I don’t blame you (I’m writing this at 3:29 a.m. Okie time), but you’re probably a little disappointed you missed a classic Cardiac Cowboys comeback.

Oklahoma State beat Arizona State 30-27 in overtime on Saturday/Sunday after the Cowboys managed to erase a  24-7 halftime deficit. Here are 10 thoughts on a wild game.

1. Big 12 After Dark

That game was as drunk as the homecoming crowd at closing time under the neon palms of J R Murphy’s.

The Cowboys looked lifeless in the first half just to entirely flip the script on the Sun Devils in the second half.

Both teams had head-scratching moments. We’ll get to OSU’s here momentarily, but it was somewhat fitting that it ended on a circus play that ended ugly and got picked off.

2. Shoutout to the OSU Defense

The Cowboys’ defense has (deservedly) taken it on the shins in recent weeks, but that unit was the hero on Saturday.

After giving up 264 yards and 24 points in the first half, OSU gave up 88 yards in the second half and overtime combined. The Sun Devils might’ve turtled a bit early, but still, the fact that this defense that has struggled of late was able to hold the line and allow the offense to get back in the game should be commended.

And for the defense to have the game-sealing play after the past few weeks, what a moment.

ASU had the ball for 8:02 of the third quarter and turned those eight minutes into just 25 yards.

The Sun Devils averaged 2.9 yards per play in the second half and 1.9 yards per rush.

Game-saving stuff.

3. Mestemaker Didn’t Practice All Week

Caleb Hawkins said he didn’t know his quarterback was playing until pregame Saturday.

Morris said freshman Broderick Vehrs took 100% of the practice reps this week. But then after going through pregame, Mestemaker felt he was ready to go.

It wasn’t his prettiest stat line. He was 30-for-40 for 294 yards and an interception (that wasn’t on him). It was his first game this season without a passing touchdown.

He did have some nice balls, with his best probably being a 34-yard over-the-shoulder ball to Justin Bowick in the third quarter on a seco nd-and-15. That play would set up a field goal that brought the Cowboys within a score.

His second-best ball was probably in overtime to Wyatt Young. It was a little high, but Young got his hands to it and couldn’t bring it in. It would’ve been an epic way to seal the comeback, but alas, the defense did it.

The fact that Mestemaker played at all, given his injury last week and his NFL future, rocks. There are probably plenty of people in Mestemaker’s position who would’ve shut it down and started doing draft prep. But not Mestemaker, and in the modern world of college football, that’s pretty cool.

4. Caleb Hawkins Was the Closer

The Cowboys, as a team, rushed for 18 yards in the first half.

Caleb Hawkins, by himself, ran for 93 yards and two touchdowns on 15 carries (6.2 per) in the second half.

He got banged up early, leading to William Mason getting some early work, but Hawkins was back to his rumbling self in the second.

The chunks he was gaining felt extra important given the hole OSU found itself in. Had he just been inching forward, the Cowboys might’ve had to abandon the run game, but credit to Hawkins and the O-line for keeping OSU balanced in the comeback.

5. Have a Day, Jerry Lawson

Defensive tackles who weigh 312 pounds aren’t supposed to have games like the one Jerry Lawson had on Saturday.

Going into Saturday, the most tackles Lawson had in an FBS football was three. He had seven against the Sun Devils, including three tackles for loss and two sacks.

OSU learned last week that an elite defensive tackle can wreck an offense, and on Saturday, they had the elite DT.

Lawson started his college career under Skyler Cassity at Abilene Christian in 2023. He also played there in 2024 before transferring to Louisville last season, where he made just 16 total tackles. He has been really good in his year as a Cowboy.

6. Plays That Suggested It Wasn’t OSU’s Day

Along with OSU just not playing very good for large portions of this game, there were moments you thought, ‘It’s just not the Cowboys’ day.’

OSU was deep in Arizona State territory in the second quarter when Mestemaker hit Terrence Lewis for what looked to be a nice gain, but as Lewis was coming down with the ball, Martell Hughes ripped it out of his hands. It went down as an interception — perhaps the least fair interception a quarterback has ever had.

Then on ASU’s ensuing drive, it looked like LaDainian Fields jumped a deep post for what would’ve been his eighth interception of the year. Instead, he could only bat the ball in the air before it fell perfectly into the waiting hands of Reed Harris for a 60-yard touchdown. It was similar to a play in the Tulsa game — a game that certainly didn’t go the Pokes’ way.

Then in the third quarter, it looked like Isaiah Chisom poked a ball away from ASU quarterback Jake Fette and Christian Bodnar recovered it, but after a lengthy review, the officials said the ball was out of bounds (or something). When asked about that play after the game, Morris was still a little hot about it, shutting the question down as to not get himself in trouble with the league.

Those plays alone perhaps should’ve been the difference in a game that ended up being close, but Big 12 After Dark, I suppose.

7. Keltner Hit Some Clutch Kicks

This game will be remembered for many different plays, but Sam Keltner hit some clutch field goals.

After hitting a 25-yard chip shot in the third quarter to make it 24-17, Keltner hit from 43 yards out with 1:11 to go to tie the game — clutch.

Then he’d hit again from 35 yards out in OT, a field goal that ended up being the game-winning points.

He’s been outstanding all year for the Pokes, but this might’ve been his best game to date given how much OSU needed the points he provided.

8. Some Major Clock Management Red Flags

OSU’s close to the first half didn’t make any sense.

Drew Mestemaker was sacked on 3rd-and-1 with 47 seconds left, and OSU used its final timeout before punting. Morris said after the game he thought it was third down, taking “1,000%” of the blame.

That gave ASU the ball back, where the Sun Devils were able to work down the field, eventually having a 4th-and-10 with 12 seconds left and the ball on OSU’s 45-yard line.

OSU came out in a prevent defense with four defenders on the goal line. That allowed ASU to throw just beyond the sticks. With the first down momentarily stopping the clock, ASU spiked it and hit a 51-yard field goal as time expired.

It was a calamity of head-scratching decisions over the span of 47 seconds that ended up costing OSU three points. In a game that went to overtime, that was almost catastrophic.

Then when OSU hit a game-tying field goal with 1:11 to play, the Cowboys came out and pooched a sky kick that was fair caught at the Arizona State 37-yard line.

It felt like the Iowa State game all over again with Arizona State just needing one chunk play to get in range for a game-winning field goal.

Morris said it was just poor execution, noting the kick needed to go further, but I’m of the belief there’s no reason to get too cute there and just kick the ball deep.

Luckily for the Cowboys, neither of those moments came back to haunt them, but that has to get cleaned up.

9. High-Leverage Downs Were Still a Bit of an Issue

As good as the Cowboys’ defense closed, there were some conversions that made you want to pull your hair out.

OSU’s D held the Sun Devils to just 3-for-15 on third down, but Arizona State was also 5-for-5 on fourth.

There was a 3rd-and-7 in the first quarter where ASU gained 40 yards. Then on the flip side, OSU had a third-and-inches on its next drive and went backward on a swing pass to Hawkins.

On an Arizona State touchdown drive in the second quarter, the Sun Devils converted on two 4th-and-1s.

On a 3rd-and-6 late in the first half, the Sun Devils gained 19 yards just before that aforementioned 60-yard touchdown to Harris.

OSU had Arizona State in a 3rd-and-15 early in the third quarter. The Sun Devils gained 14 on the play and then converted a fourth down.

The game was tied at 24 late in regulation, when ASU converted on a 4th-and-2 to keep a drive alive, which led to a go-ahead field goal.

All that is to say there were a lot of close calls that could’ve made this defensive performance look even better. This defense started the season so good in those money situations, but it’s an area that has doomed the Pokes of late.

10. The Show Goes On

It would’ve been a shame for this team that’s been mostly exciting all season to limp to a 6-6 finish, which certainly felt on the table during that first half.

It’s cool that despite last week’s game ending the team’s Big 12 title hopes that the Cowboys gritted this out. I get that these guys are getting paid to play these games now, but it would’ve been easy for the team to go, ‘Well, this one didn’t go our way,’ and move on. They didn’t do that. They kept fighting.

Most Read

Copyright © 2011- 2026 Pistols Firing Blog