Football
Instant Recap: Oklahoma State Defeats Arizona State 30-27 on Overtime Pick
The Cowboy walk it off in OT.
Support PFB with a PFB+ membership — $8 a month or $50 for a year.
The Cowboys have made a name for themselves as a second-half team this season. But this time it took some overtime theatrics to get their seventh win.
Oklahoma State defeated Arizona State 30-27 in overtime. The Cowboys had to settle for a field goal on the first possession of extra football, but then won it on the first play of ASU’s last drive thanks to a walk-off interception by safety Quinton Hammonds.
It was a game of runs. The Cowboys got off to a fast start, opening with a touchdown, and then summarily gave up 24 unanswered points to the home team. But then the Cowboys scored 17-straight of their own to tie it at 24-all early in the fourth. Then, of course, a late game became even later with a dose of overtime.
Drew Mestemaker didn’t throw a touchdown for the first time this season, but he was the reason the Cowboys climbed back into the game and had a chance to win.
Mestemaker finished 30-for-40 for 294 yards and an interception that was probably not his fault. Caleb Hawkins rushed for 98 yards and two scores and William Mason added another TD. The Pokes would rather not rely on field goals, but when they have had to, Sam Keltner has been nails. He knocked down three kicks including the game-winner.
Justin Bowick led the Cowboys with 95 receiving yards on seven catches. Wyatt Young added six for 52 yards. Eight Cowboys caught a pass from Mestemaker, who was a game-time decision.
The Cowboys’ defense had a big hand in the win, even apart from the OT interception. It held ASU to just three points over the final two quarters and overtime after a 24-point first half.
Ethan Wesloski led OSU with nine total tackles and 1.5 tackles for loss. Jerry Lawson played out of his mind, with seven tackles, three tackles for loss and two sacks.
But the game ball goes to Quinton Hammonds who logged eight tackles and the game-winning pick.
How It Played Out
After OSU’s opening-drive TD, the Sun Devils’ defense did a good job of anticipating the Cowboys’ plays. Shutting down several for a loss on third down — a shuffle pass to Mason for a loss of three and a lateral to Hawkins that got blown up for a loss of six.
While the Sun Devils’ defense kept the Cowboys on sideline, former OSU assistant Marcus Arroyo paid it off. The ASU offensive coordinator answered with a couple of touchdown drives to take a 14-7 lead midway through the second quarter.
Then, when the Cowboys were driving down the field to answer, Mestemaker threw his first pick in an unfortunate way as ASU linebacker Martell Hughes pulled a pass right out of Terrence Lewis’ mitts on his way to the ground.
Arizona State QB Jake Fette hasn’t really made a name for himself on the ground, but the freshman showed off his wheels, breaking loose on a 20-yard run on third-and-6. That quickly led to his second touchdown pass to give the home team a 21-7 lead with 1:47 left in the half.
The Cowboys had a chance to score but Mestemaker was tripped up for an 11-yard loss and sack to pull up fourth-and-14. Not only were the Cowboys held scoreless their last five possessions leading into halftime, they allowed ASU to score three more points with 42 seconds to take a 24-7 lead into the locker room.
The Cowboys took back some momentum to start the third. Jerry Lawson’s second sack of the day forced a three-and-out for ASU. Then an ugly targeting call on an impressive catch by Miles Coleman set up a first-and-goal from the 9-yard line which Hawkins paid off to make it 24-14.
It looked like Christian Bodnar was going to get the ball back for the Cowboys but after a lengthy review, the Fette fumble was not able to be overturned by review. But the Cowboys’ defense didn’t let dampen their mettle. They still turned around and forced a punt to get the ball back.
The Cowboys would cut the lead to a touchdown after settling for a field goal when a drive stalled in the red zone thanks to a false start on third-and-goal from the 3-yard-line. Regardless, the Cowboys won the third quarter, 10-0 and then continued the momentum tying it up with a touchdown drive.
For the second straight drive, OSU was flagged for a false start deep in the red zone. This time that led to a fourth-and-1 at the 7-yard line. But when ASU showed an all-out blitz, Mestemaker changed the play at the line of scrimmage and gave it to Caleb Hawkins who scooted across the goal line untouched.
Arizona State elected to go for it again on a fourth down. They were 5-for-5 on fourth down leading up to finally settling for the field goal to take a 27-24 lead with 3:12 to go. The Cowboys were able to tie it up with 1:11 to go on a Sam Keltner 43-yard kick. The Sun Devils had a shot at it but ended up playing for OT.
Overtime
Since his de facto interception in the second quarter, Mestemaker only had two incompletions over the next 19 attempts and one of those was tipped at the line of scrimmage. He also had Wyatt Young wide open in the end zone in extra time but threw just a little too high. The ball grazed off Young’s hands. After another incompletion on the next play, OSU had to settle for 3.
The Cowboys took a 30-27 lead and set up the potential walk-off win for the Sun Devils. On the first play of that drive, Fette threw the first interception of his collegiate career when Quinton Hammonds picked his ball out of the air to seal the Cowboys’ win.
good night (morning?), Tempe
@Qhammonds13 https://t.co/2r5Yjs9k0X
— OSU Cowboy Football (@CowboyFB) November 22, 2026
Next Up
With the win, the Cowboys move to 7-4 and 5-3 in Big 12 play. Next up, Oklahoma State finishes its regular season with a visit from Kansas. The Cowboys host the Jayhawks at 5:15 p.m. Saturday, Nov. 28. The game will be televised on ESPN 2.
-
Football4 days agoFour-Star Defensive Lineman Finn Walker Commits to Oklahoma State
-
Football5 days ago‘Drew’s Gonna Be OK’: Eric Morris Provides Update on Drew Mestemaker After His QB Got Banged Up Against Texas Tech
-
Football3 days agoOffensive Tackle Henry Angeley Becomes First Commitment of Cowboys’ 2028 Class
-
Football4 days agoJUCO Defensive Tackle Mahonri Maiava Commits to Oklahoma State
